As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
The 9 Best Stovetop Griddles Cook’s illustrated, America’s test kitchen of 2023
If you love to cook, then you’d understand how important making great meals at home is, regardless of how many people you intend to serve. To achieve this, you need to pay attention to your cookware, including griddles.
But how do you make the right choice to serve you perfectly, whether at camping, tailgating or at home? Trying to pin down the right one can be a daunting task since thousands of brands in the industry are offered many options.
| Image | Best Stovetop Griddles Cook | Price | Prime | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Anolon Advanced Hard Anodized Nonstick Pan/Flat Grill/Griddle Rack, 10 Inch x 18 Inch, Indigo Blue | PrimeEligible | Check Price | |
 | Lodge LPGI3 Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle, 20-inch x 10.44-inch, Black | PrimeEligible | Check Price | |
 | Lodge Cast Iron Chef Collection Rectangular Reversible Grill & Griddle - 20 in x 10 in | PrimeEligible | Check Price | |
 | OXO Good Grips Pro 11" Griddle Pan, 3-Layered German Engineered Nonstick Coating, Dishwasher Safe, Oven Safe, Stainless Steel Handle, Black | PrimeEligible | Check Price | |
 | Lodge L9OG3 Cast Iron Round Griddle, Pre-Seasoned, 10.5-inch | Prime | Check Price | |
 | Cuisinart MCP45-25NS Skillet, 10-Inch x 18-Inch, Non-Stick Double Burner Griddle | PrimeEligible | Check Price | |
 | Chef's Secret 5-Ply Stainless-Steel Pancake Pan/Griddle with See Through Glass Lid | PrimeEligible | Check Price | |
 | Ecolution Reversible 19.5” x 11, Non-Stick, Dishwasher Safe, Double Burner Family Griddle Grill Pan Cookware, Cast Aluminum, Black | PrimeEligible | Check Price |
Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:
We understand how tricky it can be, especially if this is your first time, and that’s why we’ve researched and handpicked the top 9 best stovetop griddles that should suit your cooking needs. Plus, we included a detailed buying guide section to ensure you make an informed decision.
READ ALSO: An enthusiast’s ultimate guide to griddles
Reviews of Best Stovetop Griddles Cook’s Illustrated, America’s test kitchen of 2021
Here are top-rated Stovetop Griddles on the market by consumer reports
#1 – Griddles for Stovetop America’s Test Kitchen: Anolon Hard-Anodized Nonstick
Our top recommendation is Anolon Advanced 81897 Double Burner Griddle. This model features heavy-duty aluminum construction for even heat distribution across the gourmet cooking surface for unparalleled cooking performance.
Further, the aluminum layer has a premium triple-layer nonstick coating for superb food release and hassle-free cleaning. It comes with two stainless steel handles riveted securely on both sides for easy carry even when it’s heavy with food. Also, the handles rock rubber coating to ensure it stays cool and allows a better grip.
That’s not all; Anolon Advanced 81897 Double Burner Griddle features a convenient corner spout allowing users to pour out the excess fat or other fluid without any challenge and for a mess-free cooking experience. Plus, it offers a large cooking space that sits comfortably across two burners. This way, you can handle large servings without taking a lot of time.
Anolon Advanced 81897 Double Burner Griddle offers more value with the included dishwasher-friendly mini-turner. However, it’s only oven safe to about 400 degrees F, which in our opinion, is quite low.
#2 – Lodge Pre Seasoned Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle
Taking the runner-up spot is Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle – and for a good reason. To begin with, this model comes with a large cooking space measuring 20 by 10.5 inches and sits right over two stove burners, which creates two different heat zones allowing you to cook different foods at once.
More so, this model is characterized by cast iron for incredible durability and even heat distribution across the cooking surface. This sturdy construction ensures this model can withstand high temperatures and is oven safe.
This griddle arrives already pre-seasoned using the brand’s healthy vegetable oil formula for a more natural nonstick finish, which tends to get better with use. Also, there’s a two-sided handle for easy carry and handling. Sadly, it lacks any heat-proof material, which means you need cooking gloves to hold this griddle when hot.
#3 – Rectangle Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle BY Lodge
Another spot, another Lodge grill. This model features a reversible design, which means it has a grill on one side and a griddle on the other side. This unit is very practical since it allows you to use the griddle for cooking pancakes and frying eggs, then flip it to grill steaks and fish.
Both sides also come pre-seasoned using the company’s vegetable oil for quick food release, and it’s even getting better with use. Lodge Preseasoned Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle is crafted using cast iron, which makes this unit durable and very tough.
This unit is incredibly versatile, which means you can use it on any cooktop – electric, gas, and induction. Plus, Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle is oven safe even at extreme temperatures.
However, this model’s prime concern is its lack of a channel design for easy fat draining and other unwanted fluids for safe and healthy cooking.
#4 – OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Dishwasher safe 11″ Square Griddle
This list won’t be complete without OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro 11″ Square Griddle characterized by hard-anodized aluminum construction. This way, it offers even heat distribution and incredible durability with its stainless steel encasing the griddle’s aluminum core.
More importantly, this unit has no coating, which means you don’t have to worry about this griddle scrubbing, scraping, scratching, and burning. Thanks to its sturdy stainless steel construction, this model won’t rust with time. Even better, users can soak this pan before tossing it in your dishwasher for an easy cleaning experience.
On top of that, it sports rolled edges to allow you to pour easily without dripping. Again, its contoured handles deliver a convenient grip and easy handling without getting your glove when cooking.
That’s not all; OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro 11″ Square Griddle is ideal for any cooktop surface and can withstand an oven temperature up to 430 degrees F.
#5 – Pre-Seasoned Round Cast Iron Griddle by Lodge: Best Stovetop Griddle for Pancakes
If you are in the market for the best stovetop griddle for pancakes, then you can’t really go wrong with purchasing this model. This griddle features heavy-duty construction and brings high performance to any stove. It has ample cooking space and lower sidewalls. This unit is compatible with your oven, stovetop, or campfire.
Like other products from this manufacturer reviewed on this list, this unit is seasoned with vegetable oil without synthetic materials or chemicals for safe, healthy meals. This griddle is made of high-quality cast iron for lifetime durability and cooking versatility.
#6 – Stainless Steel Double Burner Griddle BY Cuisinart
For big families, Cuisinart Double Burner Griddle is the ideal stovetop griddle. This fantastic model comes with a large cooking space to cook large servings and also entertain extra friends. This griddle features superb construction to ensure this griddle serves you for many years.
It’s made of high-quality construction and a brushed stainless exterior to enhance its durability and strength. This model distributes heat evenly for a well-cooked meal, which also eliminates any hot or cold spots.
The stainless steel handles are convenient and solid to use for easy carry. The handles feature cooling properties that keep it cool even when the grill is on fire. The griddles are perfect for cooking just about anything, thanks to their double burner design. It also includes a tight-fitting cover to seal in your food’s nutrients and moisture.
#7 – Camp Chef Professional 14″ x 32″ LARGEST Fry Griddle
Next on the list is Camp Chef Professional 14″ x 32″ Fry Griddle, which is ideal for making eggs and pancakes for breakfast. This model is capable of handling a crowd and is designed to get rid of hot spots.
Also, cleaning this model is hassle-free and comes with a convenient grease drain. Even better, this restaurant-style fry griddle comes ready to use and features a high side for a mess-free cooking experience.
#8 – Chef’s Secret Stainless-Steel 5-Ply Griddle
Looking for the best stainless steel stovetop griddle, Chef’s Secret Stainless-Steel 5-Ply Griddle is the right pick for you. This griddle is another durable yet elegant model with a stylish mirror finish.
Besides, it’s crafted with stainless steel for superior durability and long-lasting use. This unit features two handy handles to make handling a lot easier. Also, its high ridges surround the cooking surface to prevent messes when cooking.
#9 – Ecolution Non-Stick, Dishwasher Safe, Cast Aluminum Griddle Grill Pan
Last on the list is Ecolution Reversible 19.5″ x 11, Double Burner Family Griddle with a reversible design to allow you to use it as a grill and griddle. This means you can grill chicken or steak or use the other side to cook eggs, bacon, and pancakes.
Besides, this unit is dishwasher-safe and easy to clean, thanks to its premium nonstick coating. This unit offers better even heat distribution with its sturdy cast aluminum construction. This rectangular griddle is easy to use and handles large servings.
Things to Consider Before Buying Stovetop Griddles
Size
When it comes to a stovetop griddle, its cooking surface’s size is the most noticeable feature measured in square inches. However, large griddles are preferred since they allow users to cook small or large servings.
Also, large girls can be used over more than one stove burner, allowing you to cook in different heat zones. This way, you can cook on one side and use the other side low heat for food warming.
Don’t get me wrong small-size griddles can be the right choice for starters since they are cheaper or for people looking to cook small servings.
Materials
Another essential factor to put into consideration when purchasing a griddle is the material used in constructing the griddle. The most commonly used material is heavy gauge aluminum, which is usually anodized and coated with premium nonstick material. This makes the cookware corrosion-free and easy to clean.
Another prime advantage is that aluminum makes the cookware lightweight. Sadly, these aluminum griddles are not induction compatible. Further, it would be best if you considered griddles that are metal utensils safe to avoid scratching the coating off.
On the flip, cast iron griddles are more durable and tougher. They can also be used on any cooktops, including induction. Unfortunately, they are on the heavier side and need to season after each use to improve the griddle’s nonstick property.
Versatility
Most griddles have a flat cooking surface; some models on sales feature a reversible cooking surface that allows you to grill on one side and griddle on the other.
This design will always come in handy and offer good value for your money.
Oven-safe temperature
If you intend to use the cookware in your oven, you need to check the griddle’s temperature safety range. Some products are oven safe up to 500 degrees F, while others can’t handle high temperatures, especially aluminum models.
Benefits Of Stovetop Griddles
There are a couple of reasons to own a griddle or ceramic griddle, so let’s consider them one after the other.
Low learning curve
Griddle, unlike other cookware, is simple to use. They don’t require some sort of experience before using it. Gas grills or charcoal grills come with some significant drawbacks like hot spots, flareups, etc.
Also, cooking in the regular pan can be challenging due to its relatively small cooking space, which can be annoying, especially when you try flipping things. The griddle offers enough space to flip burgers, pancakes, etc.
Take more advantage of your stovetop.
For those using a stovetop griddle, it allows users to cook a lot of food simultaneously. The rectangular-shaped griddle is more space-efficient than other shapes.
While a good non-stick frying pan is an essential utensil, a griddle allows you to do much more.
Cook a wide range of foods
Griddles do more than make breakfast foods. This cookware cooks hash, browns, eggs, sausages, pancakes, pancakes; you name it. Even more, it’ll toast and do more.
Easy to clean
Some models come with a convenient grease drain design and high ridges across the perimeter for easy maintenance and cleaning after you are done cooking. Some model sports nonstick interiors for easy food release.
Conclusion
In short, stovetop griddles are one of the must-haves for any kitchen since they are ideal for making breakfast and cooking large servings without wasting time.
However, choosing the right cookware is essential, so we’ve reviewed the top 9 best stovetop griddles on the market. And, we are confident that whichever griddle you choose, you can’t really go wrong.
But if you’ve trouble making a choice, then check out our buying guide section.
See more: [Top 10] The Best Non Stick Pan America’s Test Kitchen in 2021
Thank you! Brooklyn Grill
