10 Best Electric Smokers Consumer Reports 2023

The Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker is our pick for the most reliable electric smoker. But the Char-Broil Analog electric smoker is also a great choice.

Are you looking for the best electric smoker to prepare your favorite BBQ dishes? There are a variety of electric smokers available on the market, but which one to choose? Here are the best electric smokers for your requirements.

best electric smoker consumer reports 2022
Best electric smokers 2022

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

What is the most reliable electric smoker in 2022?

The most reliable electric smoker in 2022 is the Masterbuilt MB20071117 Digital Electric Smoker. Let’s discuss it in detail.


Is it worth buying an electric smoker?

The best argument for buying an electric smoker is that they are super affordable for what they can help you do. If you’re new to smoking, you’d also find them pretty easy to use. Also, you can use smokers for making various meals


Most other kinds of smokers are more expensive than electric smokers. There are a lot of electric smokers available for less than $300.

Great versatility

Electric smokers provide a lot of flexibility if you would like to smoke different kinds of food.

For example, you can use an electric smoker for cooking desserts, seafood, sausages, and dried meats.

How do electric smokers work?

Electric smokers operate by heating a cooking chamber in which the circulation of air happens. The meat is heated by moving air, creating a convection effect. A water pan, grill racks, an electric heating element, an ash collector, and a cooking chamber are all included in an electric smoker. What’s more, high-end devices feature thermostats that allow for more accurate control of temperatures.

Best Electric Smokers Consumer Reports 2023 

Here are the other best electric smokers you can buy in 2023. 

1. Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker

Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker

Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker Product Review

+Dual door latches+Analog temperature gauge +Portable side handles

This electric smoker includes three steel cooking grills with a total cooking space of 544 sq inches. It has a total weight of 50 pounds. You could conveniently move this electric smoker from one location to another. The unit has two handles that make lifting it a breeze.

This appliance is simple to clean, operate, and assemble. The door has two latches to keep the cooking chamber warm and moist and a mounted temperature sensor for checking the internal temperature. This electric smoker is powered by a 1200-watt heating element.

A built-in water pan keeps your food moist and prevents it from drying out.

This smoker features three chrome-plated grilling grates, letting you prepare food for a large group or small family. Last but not least, it has two exhaust ports and is insulated with a double wall.

2. Char-Broil Digital Electric Smoker

Char-Broil Digital Electric Smoker

Char-Broil Digital Electric Smoker Product Review

+Remote control +Food thermometer with removable probe

The appliance’s walls are made of extremely thick steel. It is much more durable because of this double-wall structure.

It features a total of 725 square inches of cooking space with four different cooking grates, which is sufficient space to prepare a fantastic meal for a large gathering.

The locking latch of this unit has a smoke-tight seal, ensuring that both the smoke and flavor stay within. Other features of this electric smoker include a blue LED display, an advanced control panel, and a removable temperature gauge.

See also  Top 5 Best Pellet Grills Under $500 in 2023

This smoker also has built-in wheels and handles that make it easy to move around.

It also features a meat probe that can be inserted into the meat. This electric smoker will tell you if the food is already done depending on its internal temperature. What’s more, it has a glass window that lets you monitor the meat without having to open the door.

3. Dyna-Glo Digital Bluetooth Electric Smoker

Dyna-Glo Digital Bluetooth Electric Smoker

Dyna-Glo Digital Bluetooth Electric Smoker Product Review

+Digital push-button controls+Double-walled firebox+A digitally controlled meat thermometer

This smoker comes with a side wood chip loader that lets you add chips during the smoking process without needing to open the main door.

Two locks and a double-insulated cabinet ensure maximum smoke and heat retention. The unit has a cooking space of 732 sq. inches.

A built-in thermometer helps you monitor the temperature of your food, while an internal thermometer measures the temperature within.

This appliance will automatically switch off when the food reaches the temperature you want. You can operate this unit remotely with the Dyna Glo app on your tablet or smartphone as long as you are connected through Bluetooth.

This smoker is designed for a fast and easy cooking process, so you’ll be serving delicious smoked food in no time.

4. Royal Gourmet Electric Smoker

Royal Gourmet Electric Smoker

Royal Gourmet Electric Smoker Product Review

+Independent grease cup+Cool touch door handle

The electric smoker has a 1,500-watt heating element and a detachable and completely adjustable digital controller.

A built-in thermometer lets you read the internal temperature precisely, allowing you to handle your cooking temperatures.

The double-wall construction of this unit helps to maintain optimum smoke and heat. This translates to uniformly cooked food in a reasonable amount of time. This appliance’s door is also equipped with a latch that provides excellent seal performance.

A steel mesh table is attached to the front and bottom of the unit. This provides you with sufficient space to store equipment, food, and other things needed for smoking.

You will not have to worry about hurting your hands when opening or closing the appliance because it is equipped with a cool touch door handle.

5. Masterbuilt 20070210 Electric Smoker

Masterbuilt 20070210 Electric Smoker

Masterbuilt 20070210 Electric Smoker Product Review

+Integrated temperature gauge+Analog dial+Removable water bowl to add flavor and moisture

With this appliance, you may host a reunion or a small family gathering. This electric smoker gives you three racks and a cooking space of 536.3 square inches.

This model is powered by a 1500-watt heating element, and the thermostat regulates the temperature over the heating range of 100 degrees Fahrenheit to 300 degrees Fahrenheit.

You can prepare meals for 3 or 4 individuals simultaneously with this electric smoker.

A big piece of meat can be placed on the top rack and cooked nicely.

Because it uses electricity to smoke meat, this model can smoke consistently and effectively without the need to refuel or add more wood. It can smoke meat while maintaining the natural taste and flavor of the meal.

Unlike other conventional smokers, this smoker has a grease and water pan that collects debris and leaking oil from the unit.

6. Smokin-It Model #1 Electric Smoker

Smokin-It Model #1 Electric Smoker

Smokin-It Model #1 Electric Smoker Product Review

+A Rheostat for temperature control+NSF certified for use in restaurants+Perfect power chord size

The electric smoker includes three shelves and a rheostat for temperature control up to 250 degrees Fahrenheit.

It is easy to move around because it features sturdy grips on both sides. The smoking box is enormous and has ample room for the wood needed for the amount of meat that can fit in the cooking chamber.

This electric smoker can hold 21 pounds of fish or meat. You get sufficient space to cook a turkey, pounds of chicken wings, and multiple racks of ribs. This appliance has built-in temperature control to control the temperature inside.

See also  Answering All Your Questions About Dishwasher Reliability

This electric smoker is constructed from 18-gauge stainless steel to ensure maximum longevity. It has a 400-watt heating element for high smoking temperatures. In addition to this, there is fiberglass and LED light for improved insulation to make the cooking process easier.

7. Old Smokey Electric Smoker

Old Smokey Electric Smoker

Old Smokey Electric Smoker Product Review

+Fireproof handles +An advanced heat thermostat for total temperature control+Two cooking levels+Portability

This electric smoker is easy to assemble. A wood chip tray for adding wood is on the top, and an electric outlet is attached to the heating element on the bottom.

This smoker has a 1250-watt heating element and a 280-square-inch cooking space. After being switched on, this unit will reach its maximum temperature in a matter of a few minutes. It includes two cooking levels: a lower level with a lower grill and a drip pan and an upper level with an extra grill.

This electric smoker is extremely safe to use. Heat-resistant materials are used to make handles. This appliance comes with a one-year warranty. It is extremely light, weighing just 23 pounds despite being made completely from steel.

8. Bradley Digital Electric Smoker

Bradley Smoker BTDS76P 4-Rack Outdoor Electric Smoker, Digital Vertical Smoker With Stainless Steel Grill

Bradley Smoker BTDS76P 4-Rack Outdoor Electric Smoker, Digital Vertical Smoker With Stainless Steel Grill Product Review

+Smoke diffuser system+Wood smoking bisquettes

You can generate tasty, consistent, and high-quality pure smoke flavors with the 2,288-square-inch appliance’s digital interface. The smoker is easy to clean and will not rust because its interior is stainless steel.

Furthermore, this model creates smoke for nine hours without replenishing the wood.

You can readily set the timer and temperature using the digital interface. This electric smoker from Bradley makes outdoor barbecuing, smoking, and roasting a breeze.

It can reach higher temperatures, with a maximum of 320°F. This offers a vast array of possibilities for shorter smoking periods. This vertical smoker has a cooking space of 572 square inches and is powered by wood bisquettes. Bisquettes, like pellets, are efficient sources of energy that produce pleasant smoke. Pecan, cherry, hickory, alder, or apple are used to make them.

9. Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker, Black 

Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker, Black

Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker, Black Product Review

+Versatile cooking options+Even heat distribution+Low maintenance
Limited mobility

Introducing the Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker – the ultimate smoking machine that will take your culinary skills to the next level! Designed for both the novice and the seasoned smoker, this sleek appliance boasts impressive features that guarantee consistent and mouth-watering results every time. The Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker offers a generous smoking space of 711 sq. inches. Made with high-quality stainless steel, the inner material ensures maximum durability and optimal heat retention, while the corded electric power source guarantees hassle-free smoking. But what sets this smoker apart is its innovative digital controls that make smoking a breeze. The user-friendly interface lets you customize temperature and time settings, giving you full control over your cooking. Plus, the patented side wood chip loader lets you experiment with flavor without having to open the smoker door, ensuring maximum heat and smoke retention. Whether you’re a BBQ enthusiast or a professional chef, the Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker is the perfect addition to your kitchen arsenal. Experience the joy of smoking meats, fish, and vegetables with this state-of-the-art appliance that will elevate your cooking game to new heights.

10. Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker MB20071117

Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker MB20071117

Masterbuilt Digital Electric Smoker MB20071117 Product Review

+Air damper for smoke control+Wood chip tray +Thermostat-temperature control for consistent and uniform smoking+Water bowl to add flavor and moisture

This electric smoker from Masterbuilt has a chip-loading system that lets you access the wood chip pan from the side of the appliance without opening the door. This electric smoker can cook two medium pork butts, four smaller brisket flats, and 2-4 full-grown chickens. 

See also  How Much Electricity Does a Pellet Smoker Use?

It has a built-in thermostat that aids in monitoring and regulating the inside temperature.

This helps to keep the temperature and heat in the smoker consistent. This electric smoker can cook at temperatures that range from 100 to 275 degrees Fahrenheit.

The body is completely insulated, resulting in shorter cooking times, more stable temperatures, and less heat loss. Also, the door is well-sealed. This is particularly useful for people who reside in a chilly area. Finally, this smoker incorporates a latch mechanism that locks its door, preventing heat from escaping.

Of course, it is worth buying an electric smoker. An electric smoker may be a good choice, especially if you are a novice. Here are some reasons why buying an electric smoker is an excellent idea.
Easy to operate

Electric smokers are remarkably simple to operate compared to other kinds of smokers.

To operate your electric smoker, simply fill the water tray, add the chips, plug in the equipment, adjust the settings, wait for it to achieve the desired temperature, and then add the meal.

Factors to consider when buying the best electric smokers in 2023

Here are a few basic things you should know before purchasing an electric smoker. 

Dimensions and Capacity

Electric smokers are available in a variety of sizes, and the majority of them have excellent ergonomics to fit any sort of space.

Think about where you’ll keep your electric smoker, how you’ll store it, how frequently you’ll use it, and how much meat you’ll cook virtually. 

For example, if you want an electric smoker that you can use to cook food for your family, a smaller capacity electric smoker is an ideal option. On the other hand, a large smoker with a greater capacity may be ideal if you’re a frequent entertainer.


Electric smokers are far more user-friendly and convenient than charcoal smokers. This is because they are simple to light and operate.


Even if it costs a few extra dollars, you should never compromise on durability. You should

choose an electric smoker that has a warranty so that you can enjoy it for many years.

The quality of the thermostat and the seal are two major issues among electric smokers.

The electric smoker should be appropriately sealed for a more consistent temperature and heat regulation.

[amazon bestseller=”electric smoker” items=”4″ template=”table” link_id=”4832″]

Do you put the meat directly on a rack in electric smokers?

Yes, you can put the meat directly on a rack in electric smokers. Most electric smokers come with stainless steel grill racks. You can use grill racks to keep food directly on them or hold cast iron skillets to roast your meat.

Why do electric smokers not have smoke rings?

Yes, you can put the meat directly on a rack in electric smokers. Most electric smokers come with stainless steel grill racks. You can use grill racks to keep food directly on them or hold cast iron skillets to roast your meat. Several factors could lead to the lack of smoke rings in electric smokers. These could include recommended practices for smoking various kinds of food, your electric smoker’s temperature settings, and how frequently you use it.

Do you soak wood chips for a smoker?

Soaking wood chips isn’t essential for electric smokers because they usually have built-in temperature controls. However, many electric smokers are designed to accommodate wood chips. Wood chips can also help enrich the aromas of the smoke, which can increase the flavor of your food.

Which rack is hotter in an electric smoker?

All-electric smokers are hotter in the back than in the front. Additionally, they appear to have more heat at the bottom than at the top. As a result, it’s recommended to keep your meat in the back of the equipment’s bottom section. It ensures that you get appropriately cooked meat in a shorter amount of time.

Paul Goral

Paul Goral

I am the founder of Brooklyn Grill and I have a master’s degree in Engineering Acoustics. I love cooking, grilling, and trying new recipes. I also love camping and high-quality knives. I wanted to start this blog and share my passion with others.